Working With Small Presses

pink text "working with small presses" over backround of pile of open books

I have had the good fortune, strange as it sounds, to work with a different, small, independent press for each of my three adult contemporary novels. While it would have been simpler to lock in with one publisher for all of them, the experience has given me a wider perspective on how small presses work, including how their processes and offerings differ. Since other authors and readers often ask me what it’s like working with small presses, I decided to share my thoughts in this post.

I’ll explain what a small press actually is, the process of obtaining and working with one, what it does and doesn’t offer authors, and the pros and cons of working with a small press versus other options.

What is a Small Press?

First, what is a small press? It goes by several names: small press, indie press, independent publisher, small publishing house, and so on. Essentially, it’s a company that publishes your book using a traditional royalty model, but is not one of the Big 5 publishing houses: Hachette Book Group, HarperCollins, Macmillan Publishers, Penguin Random House, and Simon & Schuster. A traditional royalty model means the author pays nothing to have their book published and receives royalties, which are a portion of the profits on book sales. It’s highly unlikely you would get an “advance” on royalties with a small press; many Big 5 authors don’t even get them.

What is the Process?

Photo by Florian Klauer on Unsplash

The process of getting a contract with a small indie press, and then the process of seeing your book through publication, is very similar to the process of working with a traditional Big 5 publisher:

  1. Write a stellar novel or other work of fiction.
  2. Query small presses and convince them the world needs your book.
  3. Submit a partial or full manuscript, as requested.
  4. Possibly make edits based on the publisher’s suggestions.
  5. Sign a contract.
  6. Possibly make more edits based on the publisher’s review of the manuscript by an editor.
  7. Proof the interior file of the book known as a galley.
  8. Weigh in on, and eventually approve, the cover design.
  9. Promote the heck out of your book, with or without the publisher’s support.

How Long Does It Take a Small Press to Publish My Book?

Getting a contract with a small publisher can take months or years or might never happen at all. But once you sign a contract, small presses generally publish your book within 12-18 months.

Who Runs These Small Presses?

Two of the ones I’ve worked with have been the labor of love of one driven, committed individual, with others helping out on the edges — freelancers and part-time help. The third is slightly bigger with 6-8 staff although I’m sure many of them are part-time or freelance. It’s not a highly profitable business so this model presumably keeps overhead costs in check while delivering good results.

What Small Presses Do for Authors

Each of the three indie publishers I’ve worked with have strengths and weaknesses but, in general, such companies all provide these services:

Edit the manuscript, although the sophistication of those edits varied. The best one made strong suggestions that resulted in some re-writing and a better book, and then conducted a full “copy edit” for grammar and punctuation as well as more substantive aspects like flow and word choice. One only ran the manuscript through an AI editor.

Create the interior file, meaning everything between the front and back cover, from copyright page to final acknowledgments.

Design the cover. Many small presses require authors to submit concepts and ideas to aid the process, but they also provide a cover designer to work their magic. While they vary widely in style because of the different designers, I’ve been extremely happy with my three covers.

Put it up for sale on sites like Amazon and Ingram, which supplies many bookstores.

Arrange occasional sales of the book to attract more readers.

Manage the sales and related accounting including royalty distribution.

What Small Presses Might Do for Authors

Some of my publishers offered the following types of support but oftentimes you have to ask. Sometimes you have to cover part or all of the cost.

Enter your book into contests that only accept entries from publishers (and not from authors).

Place advertisements on social media or in book-related magazines. (The image shows an ad for my novel Beautiful and Terrible Things in Foreword Reviews.)

Arrange book giveaway promotions.

List your book with review sites like BookSirens or NetGalley, which offer your book free to advance readers in exchange for honest reviews.

Create social media posts to promote the book.

Other marketing support. One of my publishers did create a promotional poster for a book signing I scheduled at a Barnes & Noble store, and another paid for a book launch party. But overall, marketing support is slim to none, and seems to be the major gripe among indie authors who expected more from their publisher.

What Small Presses Don’t Do for Authors

In my experiences with three indie publishers, none of them provided the following services.

Get your book into bookstores.

Get your book into libraries.

Arrange book tours or other labor-intensive marketing activities.

Invest much of their own money in marketing your book.

Hold your hand. They operate on shoestring budgets with minimal staff. Whether they have 20 authors or 200, they don’t have the resources to babysit authors. However, they should be responsive when you have questions. I’ve only found one small press willing to communicate by phone. The others stick to email. Either way, keep your questions timely, relevant and professional and they should respond in kind.

Is a Small Press Worth It? Pros and Cons.

Well, if the thought of getting your book cover designed, your interior formatted and loading it onto Amazon and Ingram sends terror through your heart, then absolutely, try to land a book deal with a small press. Having an experienced industry pro guiding you through the process can be very helpful. I am grateful for everything I’ve been given by and learned from my three publishers.

Your other options are, of course, (1) obtain an agent and a book deal with one of the Big 5 publishers — an increasingly unrealistic route for most authors; or (2) self-publish your book and take on the responsibility for all of the tasks listed above. The truth is, you won’t know until you try. These days, it’s very common for an author to have some books traditionally published by a big or small press while self-publishing others.

(There is another option in which you pay to have your book published with a vanity press. Those used to have a role when the Big 5 were the only game in town. But now that there are so many quality small presses out there and self-publishing is entirely manageable, I don’t recommend paying a vanity press to publish your book.)

Whether you end up with a small press or self-publish, you’ll take on the lion’s share of the marketing responsibilities including the cost. But from what I hear, that’s even true for authors whose books are published by the Big 5 these days.

Have a question I didn’t answer? Drop it in the comments below.

Want to know more about self-publishing your book? Check out my article, 12 Steps to Self-Publishing Your Book.

If you’re wondering which companies I’ve worked with, they are: TouchPoint Press, which has since gone out of business, published Horseshoes and Hand Grenades. Black Rose Writing published Beautiful and Terrible Things. And Blydyn Square Books is publishing Unraveling Caro Dunn, which comes out in February 2027.

pink text "working with small presses" over backround of pile of open books
Photo by Rey Seven on Unsplash

Discover more from S.M. Stevens

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply